editorial decision process Archives

How Journal Editors Make Decisions: Inside the Editorial Process (What Increases Your Chances)

Last updated: January 9, 2026 | Reading time: 14 minutes Many authors believe that peer reviewers alone determine editorial outcomes. In reality, editors make the final call, combining reviewer feedback with journal scope, quality standards, ethical compliance, and editorial strategy. A deeper look at why journals reject manuscripts reveals patterns that early-career and experienced researchers […]

Types of journal decision explained

December 22, 2025 / 4 Comments

In academic publishing, journal decisions describe the editor’s formal outcome after evaluating a manuscript at different stages of the submission process. These decisions are not arbitrary labels — they reflect editorial judgment, reviewer input, journal priorities, and the feasibility of improving the manuscript. In many journals, especially those with high submission volumes, editors must make

Types of journal decision explained Read More »

academic publishing decisions, desk rejection, editorial decision process, journal submission outcomes, major revision, manuscript acceptance, manuscript rejection, minor revision, peer review outcomes, reject after peer review, responding to reviewer comments, revise and resubmit, what does major revision mean